Skip to main content
Export documents

Commercial invoice vs proforma invoice: which one customs needs

A proforma invoice is a quotation-style invoice a supplier sends before shipment, usually so the buyer can pay a deposit or arrange an import licence. A commercial invoice is the final bill for the goods actually shipped, and it is the document customs uses to value and classify them.

US regulations set out what a commercial invoice must contain, from a detailed description of the goods to the country of origin and every charge itemised by name and amount. If the commercial invoice is not available at entry, US rules allow a pro forma invoice with a written declaration and a bond, and the commercial invoice must follow within 120 days.

Quick answer

Proforma = before shipment, for payment and planning; commercial invoice = after shipment, for customs.

Pay a deposit against a proforma invoice, but make sure the supplier issues a commercial invoice for the goods actually shipped, with the details customs asks for. In the US a pro forma invoice is only a stopgap at entry, backed by a bond.

Key takeaways: ask the supplier for the commercial invoice and packing list before the goods are loaded, and check the description, quantities, values and origin against your order.

Two invoices, two jobs

US rules quoted from 19 CFR.

Proforma invoice

Sent before shipment: price, terms, payment details.

Commercial invoice

Final invoice for shipped goods; customs uses it for entry (19 CFR 141.81).

Missing invoice (US)

Pro forma plus a declaration and a bond; commercial invoice within 120 days (19 CFR 141.91).

Bond (US)

One and one-half times the invoice value (19 CFR 141.91).

Best for

  • Importers paying a deposit to a Chinese supplier for the first time
  • Buyers asked by customs or a broker for the commercial invoice

Not best for

  • Sending customs the proforma when the shipped goods changed
  • Undervalued invoices, which create duty and penalty risk for the importer

What to prepare

  • The supplier's proforma and commercial invoices and the packing list
  • Your purchase order or agreed product list

Proof examples

  • Description is specific enough for classification, not just "parts" or "samples"
  • Quantities and unit prices match the order and the packing list
Side by side

Commercial invoice vs proforma invoice

Customs points from US regulations (19 CFR 141.81 to 141.91); other countries have similar but not identical rules.

Topic Proforma invoiceCommercial invoice
When it is issued Before production or shipmentWhen the goods ship
What it is for Quotation, deposit payment, import licence or letter of creditFinal bill and the basis for customs value and classification
Customs entry (US) Only as a stand-in with a written declaration and a bondPresented for each shipment when the entry summary is filed
Content Expected goods, prices and termsActual goods shipped, with the details customs requires
Can it change? Yes, it is provisionalIt should match what was shipped; corrections need explaining
Checklist

What a US commercial invoice must show

Summarised from 19 CFR 141.86(a). Other countries ask for similar content; check the destination's rules.

Item What to include
Parties and sale Seller and buyer, and the time and place of sale
Port of entry The US port where the goods will be entered
Description A detailed description of the merchandise
Quantities Quantities in weights and measures
Price Purchase price in the currency of the purchase
Charges All charges itemised by name and amount, including freight, insurance and commission
Rebates and assists Rebates, drawbacks and assists such as dies or molds supplied by the buyer
Origin The country of origin
Package marks The marks and numbers of the packages
Who this helps

Check both invoices before money and goods move.

The proforma controls what you pay up front; the commercial invoice controls what customs charges. Errors in either cost money.

Best for 01

Importers paying a deposit to a Chinese supplier for the first time

Best for 02

Buyers asked by customs or a broker for the commercial invoice

Best for 03

Small businesses preparing documents for a duty-paid or DAP shipment

Before you accept the term

What to check on a supplier's invoices

Compare the proforma, the commercial invoice and the packing list line by line.

Quote inputs · 4 items

What to send JTLGO

  • The supplier's proforma and commercial invoices and the packing list
  • Your purchase order or agreed product list
  • Destination country and whether you or a broker will clear customs
  • Incoterm agreed with the supplier
Control checks · 4 items

Invoice checks

  • Description is specific enough for classification, not just "parts" or "samples"
  • Quantities and unit prices match the order and the packing list
  • Freight, insurance and other charges are itemised where required
  • Country of origin and package marks are stated
Risk flags · 4 items

Common invoice mistakes

  • Sending customs the proforma when the shipped goods changed
  • Undervalued invoices, which create duty and penalty risk for the importer
  • Vague descriptions that delay classification
  • Invoice totals that do not match the payment actually made
When to use which

Which invoice for which step

Route note 01 Guidance

Use the proforma to agree price and pay the deposit; keep it with your payment records.

Route note 02 Guidance

Use the commercial invoice for customs entry and for your accounts once the goods ship.

Route note 03 Guidance

For duty-paid shipments, the logistics provider still needs an accurate invoice value to pay duty and tax.

Route note 04 Guidance

JTLGO checks the invoice and packing list against the goods it receives before quoting the export route.

Reference sources: 19 CFR 141.86: contents of invoices (LII copy of eCFR) · 19 CFR 141.91: commercial invoice not available at entry (LII copy of eCFR) · 19 CFR 141.85: pro forma invoice (LII copy of eCFR) · 19 CFR 141.81: invoices for each shipment (LII copy of eCFR)

FAQ

Invoice questions

What is the difference between a proforma invoice and a commercial invoice?

A proforma invoice is issued before shipment to set out expected goods, prices and terms, often for a deposit payment. A commercial invoice is issued when goods ship and records what was actually sent; customs uses it to value and classify the goods. In the US, a commercial invoice is presented for each shipment at entry.

Can I clear customs with a proforma invoice?

In the US, only as a stopgap. Under 19 CFR 141.91, if the commercial invoice is not available, the importer files a written declaration, a pro forma invoice and a bond of one and one-half times the invoice value, and must produce the commercial invoice within 120 days after filing the entry summary.

What must a commercial invoice include?

For US imports, 19 CFR 141.86 requires the port of entry, seller and buyer, a detailed description, quantities, the purchase price in the currency of purchase, itemised charges such as freight and insurance, rebates and assists, the country of origin, and the marks and numbers of the packages.

Who issues the commercial invoice?

The seller, which for goods from China is usually the supplier or the exporter of record. If an agent buys for you, the invoice should still describe the actual goods and the price paid. Ask for it before the goods are loaded so you can check it against your order.

Does JTLGO need my supplier's invoice?

Yes, for most shipments. JTLGO needs an accurate description and value to choose the route and, for duty-paid lines, to pay duty and tax. When goods arrive at its warehouse in China, JTLGO compares them with the invoice and packing list before export.